From what we've seen so far, do you feel you're going to stay with PoE1 or move to PoE2?

"
1453R#7804 wrote:
Baumis, you are declaring that your assertions based on prerelease, in-development footage from curated events for a game currently in heavy flux are all somehow etched in titanium and will be how PoE2 is until the End of All Time and Space. It is exhausting listening to you argue for three pages about how the dodge roll is dogshit because this one clip from one streamer in one event shows a lack of i-frames and that means the entire mechanic is DOA Forever. That is not a useful argument to make. It is a waste of everyone's time because it does not matter one frog fornication whether or not Ziggy managed to iframe away from Long Chungus or not because the game likely already HAS changed since then, and will absolutely change after it drops.

A mechanic can look at a car and figure out stuff, yes. Can the same mechanic look at drawings and schematics for an in-development, unfinished, barely half-built car and make the same assumptions with the same degree of certainty? NO!

There's a reason I respect Phrazz's stance on PoE2 and pay attention when he speaks up while you just make me Double Facepalm. You are invincibly lost in meaningless minutiae that WILL change before the game's official full launch, and it renders basically all of your arguments largely useless. Not necessarily incorrect within their context, but useless - because that context almost certainly no longer applies.


Well, this just aged like milk, didn't it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/pathofexile/comments/1h8lf9y/dodge_roll_should_give_phasing/

I don't want to be all "I told you so.", but: I told you so.
Gaming PC: Win 11, 7600X3D, RTX 4080, 32GB DDR5-6000 CL30, 7000 MB/s SSD, 850W, 3840x2160p 120Hz
Streaming PC: Win 11, i5-12400, RTX 4060, 32GB DDR5-6000 CL36, 7000 MB/s SSD, 450W, 1920x1080p 60Hz
What did they leave in POE2 that we liked in POE1? Nothing, except the setting. They cut 90% of the crafting, 90% of the mechanics, added ridiculous rolls and "EPIC" boss battles. They simplified everything they could, just so that console players wouldn't have any trouble understanding the game. Maybe Twitch soyjacks will appreciate it, but I don't need it. If I want to play Dark Souls, I'll play Dark Souls. So the choice is obvious. The developers made the game not for POE1 players, but for themselves (I want to believe it) and idiot streamers.
Last edited by bachgaman#6713 on Dec 7, 2024, 3:53:51 AM
I predicted that it wanted to become the dark souls of arpgs.

https://www.pathofexile.com/forum/view-thread/3407628

Also in my opinion the fireball and spark skill effect look much worse than the cool poe 1 versions from 2013. These effects don't showcase power like they do/did in poe 1.

POE 1 was designed for the pc fanbase. This is how a pc game looks and feels:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NDFO4E5OKSE&t=96s
Heart of Purity

Awarded 'Silverblade' to Talent Competition Winner 2020.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NDFO4E5OKSE
POE 2 is designed primarily for console.
Last edited by Reinhart#6743 on Dec 7, 2024, 4:00:44 AM
Poe 2 for sure. This warrior playstyle is perfect and the difficulty is great, love a bit of a challenge
Based on day 1 balance I would go back to poe 1. Will see where we get to though. It is early access after all.
"
title

edit: d4 bad


Well I don't play PoE 1, tried it about 5 years ago wasn't for me. Been waiting for PoE 2. I'm not a huge souls like player but I do like the slower pace and feel this is dark and gritty and what really D4 should of been.

I've played a lot of Last epoch waiting for this and getting used too the gameplay. PoE 2 is a beautiful game I'm 21 lvl lets see how the game feels with gear latter on.

TBH, GGG appears to have decided to go down the Dark Souls path, but it has none of the benefits of a DS game...no first person, no close in third person. In fact, I would call this game 75% DS, 25% aarpg. If I wanted to play a DS game, I would play a DS game. I played for a bit last night and TBH, not really interested in playing any more as I'll probably head back to POE.
As i've said many times POE 1 is not POE. POE died in 3.15. They've used POE as a testing ground for POE 2 so much it's not even the same game and you'd know this if you got to play before 3.15. visually and mechanically they've ruined poe for poe 2.

I won't be playing either. they can pay all the streamers in the world to hype up the games but luckily I'm not a zoomer and can resist it.
I think it's hilarious the salt in here claiming the game is a dark souls clone because... you have to dodge? Dark souls didn't invent dodging damage folks.
"
As i've said many times POE 1 is not POE. POE died in 3.15. They've used POE as a testing ground for POE 2 so much it's not even the same game and you'd know this if you got to play before 3.15. visually and mechanically they've ruined poe for poe 2.

I won't be playing either. they can pay all the streamers in the world to hype up the games but luckily I'm not a zoomer and can resist it.


3.14 was the last great moment in arpg history imo. I didn't hate PoE after that, but it hasn't been that good since. LE has potential. D4 is turd sauce. PoE 2 isn't the worst thing ever so far, but I don't feel any fomo when I log out.

Report Forum Post

Report Account:

Report Type

Additional Info