[Suggestion] Death penalty design change

tl;dr: Visual example:


This does not even suggest removing death penalty. Its the same penalty, all it does is allow you to sit at a snapshot of xp somewhere else other than 0% to 10%


Envisioned result:
Dying still hurts, but crawling back has that light in the tunnel where if you crawl out even 1%, you slowly are winning. More fun overall than getting to a content that blasts you a few times and you forgot you were at 95% exp and now 8h of progress is gone (hint: not fun).

way too complicated, just make it so if you die in a map you lose the xp for that map

"

tarloch#1873 wrote:

way too complicated, just make it so if you die in a map you lose the xp for that map

+1

"

tarloch#1873 wrote:

way too complicated, just make it so if you die in a map you lose the xp for that map

Which part is complicated ? Did you read the OP ?

yes and i made my head spin, -10%, -2%, -10%
im not very smart, to me 12% xp to next level means you are on 88%. perhaps you could explain it easier?
but why bother, just do as i suggested
ever heard of the term KISS

I wasn't following when reading the bullet points but the explanation afterwards is pretty clear - cap the XP loss at the maximum XP reached minus 10%. This means you can't just keep going backwards but you certainly could stall.

Losing the XP for that map would also be a big improvement in my view.

thank you, so you are saying if i am on 4% xp i can only lose 10% of that.
meaning i am now on 3.6% xp

ok got it so instead of a flat 10% its based on the xp currently held. which means it gets worse as you level, die at 99.9% and lose 9.9% xp.

the suggestion is better but one of my gripes about the penalty is that it is retroactive which the suggestion still is
just losing the xp for the map solves that and you still stall if you die

"

tarloch#1873 wrote:

way too complicated, just make it so if you die in a map you lose the xp for that map

THIS!

I could also agree on a system that makes the XP loss dependent on how often you die within a certain amount of maps completed, e. g. each completed map reduces the XP loss by 1% so if you complete 10 maps without dying, the next death costs no XP.

That way you still keep the bad builds from progressing, but the occasional one-shot or the overly deadly mod doesn't set the players back that much.

Guess I will have to create a visual example...
(added to OP)

And the idea to lose only XP one obtains in a map or rather recently, is really just removing the whole penalty for dying altogether and is a much more complex design change.
How would this work during campaign exactly ? How do you decide when a new XP counter is started that counts how much you have gained ? In endgame, sure you could track XP obtained in a particular map from the map device. So one can farm a little bit of that map and create a new one and never fear for xp loss again ?

Please if you have a completely separate idea, draft a design and create a new thread.