What do you think will happen to That Which Was Taken?

"

Aynix wrote:

Ah yes, "we shouldnt add good items to the game because they will be mandatory!".
If GGG followed this flawed mindset we would never see chase items in this game.

That would be a marked improvement as I see it. Then the game would have to focus on being intrinsically enjoyable to play, rather than dangling carrots in front of people.

Anyway, I don’t see why being rare and powerful (a “chase item”) has to mean accepting things with such generic application. Still prefer unique design that says some of them will be good for some builds but bad for others (whether through active downsides or just substantial opportunity cost from gaps in stats). Not “literally every build benefits from having one of these”.

They're cool, but we don't need more obviously mandatory jewels. I do like the way they give access to lines from other ascendencies.

If I had to guess, they're not sending this core.

They shouldn't go core as it's just another layer of unnecessary power creep that we don't really need as the game is already spoiled enough with pure player power.
It would be somewhat fine if they dump down the power of the item to just 2 random charm mods, instead of 4 and add it as a random drop. Just because some interactions might or might not enable some interesting builds. But I guess that doesn't really matter anyways with 90% of the player base playing and following just some ooga booga streamer meta builds anyways.
Or with items like The Adorned it's clearly viable that power creep doesn't really matter anymore and we already reached the point of playing D3 just in Wraeclast with the ever growing player power. hoho

i think its fine if it goes legacy.

im all for expensive items and chase stuff but do we really need this one? it kind of waters down the importance of ascendancies a bit, were taking away individuality and importance of choices from the build game and just sayings its ok, if you are rich you can just buy your way out of a lot of those decisions being tradeoffs.

i like watchers eye, thats a great jewel, the whole pick n mix idea for jewels is really cool. i do like TWWT for a league but i think as a core feature its problematic.


the idea of making it 2 stats only is interesting, i think thats a lot more reasonable.

its so good to wake up early, make coffee and read what you guys think

"

ArtCrusade wrote:

"

Aynix wrote:

Ah yes, "we shouldnt add good items to the game because they will be mandatory!".
If GGG followed this flawed mindset we would never see chase items in this game.

Well sorry for having a different opinion (like the majority on the strawpoll btw hoho)

I think you need to go back to school to learn how to count.

9 votes - it will go legacy. (so its gone)
18 votes - it will stay in the game (either as boss drop, card drop or just affliction league goes to core)

"

Aynix wrote:

I think you need to go back to school to learn how to count.

9 votes - it will go legacy. (so its gone)
18 votes - it will stay in the game (either as boss drop, card drop or just affliction league goes to core)

This is the true PoE player - no jokes - he understands the mathematics of things and when he C, he C what others cant C

That Which Was Taken looks like Watchers "second edition".
I believe it will surely go to core, maybe some affixex that are too OP will be nerfed in 3.24 or later.

It will come to standard, unchanged though be legacy from then on.

We're in the twilight years of PoE 1 and GGG is being generous to those who're sticking around till the end. We can make a mirror in a couple of weeks this league ffs. I stopped playing for 4 years when harvest and synth league was around, but I don't think we've ever had anything anywhere near close to this level of currency generation.

It's like GGG has given us a pension boost for PoE 1's retirement.

Charm and TWWT jewel shouldn't go to core. If so, then a massive nerfs will be warranted if both go to core. The ceiling can be higher or stayed the same, but the floor will get lower. 4 ascendancy powers from various characters, condensed into a jewel, is extremely powerful, and as well as charm albeit fewer and need primalist ascendancy class. IF TWWT is not just a jewel, but a gear, then it would be understandable.